My favourite Yiddish saying is mensch tracht un Got lacht.
Translation: A man plans and God laughs.
The common understanding of the phrase is that life is unpredictable, in spite of our best-laid plans. It's usually said when we've worked really hard to achieve a specific objective, things go wrong in an unforeseen way, and the effort feels futile. It's also a statement about human humility, because only God knows the final outcomes.
But I've always brought another interpretation to it, with an emphasis on Got lacht. To me, it means something like this: mankind considers rationality to be the highest pursuit, but it's having a sense of humour that brings us closer to the Divine. Laughter is Godly.
In other words, laughter is no laughing matter. It's profound.
Plenty has been written about humour, and in particular Jewish humour. Since the 20th century, Jews have been disproportionately represented in American comedy writing and performing, from the Marx Brothers to Woody Allen to Seinfeld. In 1978, Time magazine famously estimated that roughly 80% of American stand-up comedians were Jewish.
Genuine laughter is a moment of vulnerability. To laugh, you must let your guard down, if only for an instant. That's why we love comedians. They have the power, through their art, like all great artists, to allow us to let our guard down. It's why laughter feels so liberating.
I'm talking about genuine laughter, not the kind that seems forced. There's nothing more telling than a forced or self-conscious laugh. You immediately distrust a person who has a fake or forced laugh.
And that's because there's nothing more revealing than a person's laugh. Think of Trump's laugh. Have you ever seen him laugh? Or even smile? You get the picture.
Laughter is so revealing because it's multifaceted. It comes in so many varieties. There's joyful laughter. Contagious laughter. Knowing laughter. Helpless laughter. Absurd laughter. Nervous laughter.
Sometimes, when my wife and I are arguing, I'll laugh at what seems like an inappropriate moment. And she will rightly take offence. Why are you laughing? she'll ask. And I'll answer, Because what you're saying is making me very uncomfortable, and I'm feeling insecure.
The laughter of nervous insecurity.
Humour contains within it how a people feel about their lives and how they engage with the people around them. It's a socio-political indicator.
When I was studying Russian at university, we often learned Russian jokes because they helped us understand the Russian attitude and mentality, which is so important when learning a language. Incidentally, this was during the Soviet era, so Russian jokes were often subversive, grounded in how powerless people felt and how absurd life was.
For Jewish people, humour usually has a tinge of sadness and tragedy that reflects our history. When a people is powerless and persecuted, it's often through their sense of humour that they can express a rare act of rebellion.
As someone who grew up during the heyday of American and Canadian humour, it's very apparent to me that it's been in decline for a few decades. My generation, the baby boomers, was defined by the greatest period of television variety shows and sitcoms. From The Carol Burnett Show to All in the Family and its multiple spin-offs, to M*A*S*H*. From Saturday Night Live to SCTV to The Kids in the Hall. Television was funnier, books were funnier, and movies were funnier.
The humour that does exist these days tends to be artless, cheap and crude, leaning on rudeness, and people making embarrassing spectacles of themselves. Think Jackass and Impractical Jokers.
Why has the quotient and quality of humour in our culture declined?
Comedy challenges taboos and breaks down barriers between people through satire, irony and wit. It shines a light on the social constructs that differentiate us, and connects us to one another on a more vulnerable and universal level. It brings us together.
In a cultural environment excessively preoccupied with hugging personal identities (racial, religious, sexual, political, etc.) as closely as possible, comedy represents a threat. When we take our ourselves too seriously, when we become more socially rigid, we take offence when our differences are being attacked.
The bottom line is that we resist seeing the common humanity in one another.
Which brings me back to Got lacht. When we can laugh with others and laugh at ourselves, we briefly commune with the Godliness in ourselves and our common humanity. That's just how vital laughter is to our personal and social well-being, being able to see the humanity in each other.
No comments:
Post a Comment